Parshas Vayetzei – 5787 – Intriguing Questions & Answers
Ask The Rav
Honoring One’s Father Regarding Political Elections
Q: An important question arises regarding the mitzvah of kibbud av va’eim. During elections, whether in Eretz Yisrael for the government or in the United States for president or other government positions, if a father asks his son to vote for the candidate whom he believes is best suited for the position, is the son obligated to obey his father because of the mitzvah of kibbud av, or is there no obligation to follow his instructions?
A: We have already discussed this subject at length in my sefer Ohel Yaakov, Hilchos Kibbud Av Va’eim. See there for further details.
Briefly, we will mention the ruling of the Maharik (shoresh 166), cited in the Darchei Moshe (Yoreh Deah 240:10), regarding a father who objects to his son marrying the woman of his choice. The Maharik explains that the obligation of honoring one’s father applies to matters such as feeding him and similar acts that directly concern the father. However, regarding matters in which the father has no personal involvement, it is obvious that he has no authority to prevent his son from acting according to his wishes. However, the Makneh (Kiddushin 31a) maintains that even when the father derives no personal benefit from the matter, it is nevertheless included in the mitzvah of mora av (reverence for one’s father), since disobeying his instructions is considered contradicting his words.
Similarly, Rabbi Akiva Eiger writes that this is included in the obligation of reverence, which requires a person to be careful not to violate his parents’ instructions.
However, regarding our question of whether a son must be stringent and follow his father’s instructions concerning whom to vote for, there is room for consideration. Even if we assume that we follow the stringent opinions mentioned above, which maintain that acting against one’s father’s instructions constitutes a violation of mora av, we may still rely on those opinions that consider such conduct no more severe than contradicting one’s father’s words. Regarding contradicting one’s father, there are lenient opinions that permit doing so when the father is not present. See Shu”t Even Yisrael, Vol. IX (siman 87), and Shu”t Be’er Moshe, Vol. VIII (simanim 59–61). An additional consideration can be suggested based on the ruling of the Tur and Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah 240:5), that the financial obligation of honoring one’s father is fulfilled using the father’s money and not the son’s. Accordingly, if the son believes that a particular candidate would benefit him more, such as by providing greater financial assistance from government funds to the country’s residents or similar benefits, the mitzvah of kibbud av does not obligate the son to spend his own money. Consequently, there is no obligation to follow his father’s instructions in this matter, particularly when the father is not present.
Halachah Lemaaseh: There are grounds to be lenient and permit the son to vote according to his own judgment, even if his father has instructed him otherwise. Nevertheless, one who wishes to be stringent and follow his father’s wishes is deserving of a berachah. He will certainly also gain the mitzvah of bringing happiness to his father and mother.
Tachanun at Minchah When the Chuppah Is After Sunset
Q: If a chassan is getting married after sunset, should the congregation recite Tachanun at Minchah?
A: The Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 131:4) rules that a chassan does not recite Tachanun from the day of his wedding until the conclusion of the seven days of Sheva Berachos. Similarly, a congregation that davens together with the chassan does not recite Tachanun because of his presence.
We find a disagreement among the poskim regarding whether the chassan himself should recite Tachanun at Minchah when his wedding will take place after sunset.
In Shu”t Shevet HaLevi, Vol. VII (siman 18), he writes that the chassan himself does not recite Tachanun at Minchah on the day of his wedding, even when the chuppah will take place after sunset. However, Orchos Rabbeinu, Vol. III (page 210), cites the Chazon Ish as ruling that a chassan recites Tachanun on his wedding day until he actually enters the chuppah. Each person should therefore follow his custom and the guidance of his rabbanim. Regarding the congregation davening Minchah with the chassan when the wedding will take place after sunset, the Birkei Yosef (131:5) writes that even when the chuppah is after sunset, Tachanun is not recited at the Minchah immediately preceding the chuppah. However, Halichos Shlomo, Hilchos Tefillah (Chapter 11, note 11), cites Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l as ruling that if the chuppah will take place after sunset, Tachanun should be recited at Minchah, even by the chassan himself. In Ishei Yisrael (Chapter 25, note 82), the author relates that he heard from Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l that when a congregation davens shortly before the chuppah, if the chassan is davening together with them, they should not recite Tachanun. However, if the chassan is not davening with them, they should recite Tachanun, even if everyone has gathered there for the wedding.
When Is a Chassan Considered to Be Davening with the Congregation:
Regarding cases in which Tachanun is omitted, we must clarify what constitutes a chassan davening together with the congregation. For example, a chassan enters the shul while the congregation is davening Shemoneh Esrei or beginning Tachanun. However, he is not davening with them, since he intends to daven with the next minyan.
The Eshel Avraham (siman 131) writes: “When he is in a public shul or beis medrash but is not davening at all with those who are presently davening, and has not even put on his tallis and tefillin because he intends to daven with a later minyan, according to all opinions his presence does not prevent the congregation from reciting Tachanun. “This is because the chassan is considered joined with the congregation only when he davens together with them, even if they are not all in the same location. However, when he is learning while they are davening, this does not apply. “Nevertheless, having the chassan leave to learn in an adjoining room is a practical solution.”
We see from his words that everything depends on whether the chassan actually davens with the congregation. If he intends to daven with another minyan, his presence does not exempt the congregation from Tachanun. This is also the opinion of Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l, as cited in Shu”t Avnei Yashfeh, Vol. I (siman 21, section 2), and in Mishnas HaGrish. He rules that a chassan does not exempt the congregation from Tachanun unless he davens Shemoneh Esrei together with them, even if he remains in the shul throughout the entire davening.
This ruling is also cited in Yismach Lev. Similarly, I heard from my rebbi, Maran Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl shlit”a, that if a chassan is sitting and learning inside the shul but is not davening with the congregation, they are not exempt from reciting Tachanun. However, I saw that Rav Nissim Karelitz zt”l maintained that in such a case, the congregation is indeed exempt from reciting Tachanun. His reasoning is that the entire congregation has an obligation to bring happiness to the chassan, and through this, everyone shares in the simchah. Therefore, there is no distinction between whether the chassan davens with them or not. He adds that this explains the ruling of the Taz (siman 131), who writes that lechatchilah, a chassan should not enter the shul in order to avoid preventing the congregation from reciting Tachanun.
The Taz does not make the same statement regarding the participants in a bris milah, since in that case Tachanun is omitted because of the mitzvah associated with the bris, rather than because of the congregation’s joy. However, regarding a chassan, the congregation is obligated to bring him happiness. Therefore, he should preferably not enter the shul and thereby impose this halachic consequence upon them.
Bishul Akum When a Non-Jew Lights the Fire Under Cholent
Q: An incident occurred in a large shul where many pots of cholent were prepared for a large kiddush on Shabbos morning. However, on Erev Shabbos, they noticed that a non-Jew had lit the fire beneath the cholent, which was already fully cooked. Would it help for a Jew to remove the pot from the fire and then return it?
A: The Rema (Yoreh Deah 113:9) writes that one may be lenient when a non-Jew cooks food until it reaches the stage of ma’achal ben Derusai (partially cooked), and a Jew then completes the cooking. In such a case, the food does not become prohibited because of bishul akum. However, see Pischei Teshuvah (113:4), who cites the Shelah as being stringent in this matter. Nevertheless, in our case, on Erev Shabbos, even according to the Shulchan Aruch, there is room for leniency. However, the above reasoning does not help in our case, since the cholent was already fully cooked.
Nevertheless, there is another basis for permitting it, based on Shu”t Avnei Nezer (Yoreh Deah, siman 100).
The Avnei Nezer introduces a leniency even regarding food that has already been fully cooked, provided that it is considered mitztamek v’yafeh lo — food whose quality improves as it continues cooking and reduces.
In such a case, further cooking performed by a Jew is still effective. Accordingly, the same applies to cholent, which is considered mitztamek v’yafeh lo. Therefore, it is effective for a Jew to remove the pot from the fire and then place it back again. This was also the ruling of the author of Shu”t Meshiv Nevonim. However, all of this applies when the situation is discovered on Erev Shabbos. If they discover what happened only on Shabbos itself, and in order to avoid the prohibition of bishul akum, a Jew would need to remove the pot and return it to the fire, there may be room for leniency based on the halachos of chazarah (returning food to a heat source on Shabbos). However, one must be particularly careful regarding bones in the cholent, since there is a disagreement among the poskim as to whether they are considered fully cooked. Therefore, in such a situation, one must consult a rav regarding the proper way to resolve the issue without violating any of the prohibitions of Shabbos.
Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabbanim of Beis Horaah KLY:
What bracha should be made when eating many dounuts?
Q: What bracha rishonah and bracha acharonah should I make if I eat five doughnuts in one sitting?
A: The hardest part of asking the Rav this shailah may be admitting how many doughnuts you ate. It comes up often enough on Chanukah to deserve an answer. Let us begin with pas haba’ah b’kisnin, the halachic category of baked goods usually eaten as snacks, such as sweet pastries and crackers.
The usual brachos on pas haba’ah b’kisnin are Borei Minei Mezonos and Al Hamichyah. The Gemara teaches that when a person is kovea seudah on it, meaning that he eats an amount people ordinarily eat as a meal, it takes on the halachos of bread. He washes, makes Hamotzi, and recites Birchas Hamazon afterward. This applies even if he is still hungry after eating that amount (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 168:6).
How much is considered a meal? The Mishnah Berurah (168:24) cites Acharonim who use the measure of a meal for an eiruv techumin. An eiruv techumin is made by placing two meals’ worth of food at a designated spot before Shabbos so that one’s Shabbos walking limit is measured from that spot. For this purpose, one meal is three or four beitzim (egg-volumes), depending on the opinion (see Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 368:3). The Mishnah Berurah then writes that most Acharonim measure a meal by the amount people ordinarily eat at a regular morning or evening meal. He adds that l’chatchilah one should avoid eating four beitzim of pas haba’ah b’kisnin outside a bread meal. In our case, the five doughnuts are full-sized and together meet both measures.
Chanukah doughnuts are usually deep-fried, which brings us to a different machlokes. The Mishnah (Challah 1:5) rules that dough described as techilaso issah v’sofo sufganin, meaning that it starts as a dough and ends up as a cooked or deep-fried, doughnut-like pastry, is subject to hafrashas challah. Rabbeinu Tam and Rabbeinu Shimshon agree that hafrashas challah is required if the dough was originally kneaded for baking and the baker later decided to fry it. They disagree about whether the Mishnah also applies when the dough was made from the outset to be cooked or fried. Rabbeinu Tam holds that even in this case, a firm dough is subject to challah. Rabbeinu Shimshon holds that dough made for frying from the outset and then fried is exempt (see Tosafos, Pesachim 37b, s.v. d’kulei alma, Rabbeinu Shimshon on Challah 1:5, and Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah 329:3).
For brachos, Rabbeinu Tam treats fried dough as bread. If the dough itself is sweet enough to qualify as pas haba’ah b’kisnin, the bracha is Mezonos when a small amount is eaten as a snack. In his view, eating a meal-sized portion requires Hamotzi and Birchas Hamazon. The first opinion in the Shulchan Aruch follows Rabbeinu Shimshon and treats deep-fried dough as a cooked grain dish. Even a meal-sized portion therefore calls for Mezonos and Al Hamichyah. The Rema records that the custom follows this opinion. The Shulchan Aruch advises a yerei Shamayim to satisfy both views by first making Hamotzi on ordinary bread. The Rema likewise considers it praiseworthy to eat the doughnuts only as part of a bread meal.
Summary: If you plan to eat a meal-sized portion of sweet, deep-fried doughnuts, l’chatchilah you should eat them as part of a bread meal. Plan to eat at least a kebeitzah of ordinary bread so that you can recite Al Netilas Yadayim when you wash according to all opinions. If you are eating only a kezayis of bread, wash without a bracha (see Mishnah Berurah 158:9). Have the doughnuts in mind when making Hamotzi, eat the bread first, and recite Birchas Hamazon after the meal. If you eat the doughnuts on their own, the lenient minhag recorded by the Rema is to make Mezonos and recite Al Hamichyah afterward. This applies even if you eat a very large amount, provided the dough was made for frying from the outset.
