Parshas Chayei Sara – 5787 – Intriguing Questions & Answers

Rabbi Yaakov Aron Skoczylas   -  

Ask The Rav

Are We Required to Check Mezuzos Nowadays

Q: A common question that arises in Jewish homes concerns whether mezuzos must be checked periodically, even after they were checked before being affixed. Perhaps, since there is little concern that they will become damaged, there is no need to check them again.

A: The source for the obligation to check mezuzos is the Gemara in Yoma (11b), which states that a privately owned mezuzah must be checked twice every seven years, while a public mezuzah must be checked twice every fifty years. This is also ruled in Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah 291:2). Rashi explains that the concern is that the mezuzah may have decayed or been stolen. The Meiri adds that the letters may have become blurred, since even one blurred letter can invalidate a mezuzah.

The Rambam (Hilchos Mezuzah 5:9) writes that a privately owned mezuzah must be checked twice every seven years, and a public mezuzah twice every fifty years, lest a letter have torn or become erased due to decay from being affixed to the wall.

Regarding the definition of checking twice within seven years, must one check every three and a half years, or is this not necessarily required? From the straightforward wording of the poskim, it appears that one should check every three and a half years. Furthermore, even if the mezuzah was checked well before the end of that period, the next three-and-a-half-year period begins from the date of the most recent inspection. However, the Chut Shani explains that the requirement to check a mezuzah twice every seven years means that seven full years should not pass without an inspection. After all, when one initially affixes the mezuzah, it is certainly a checked mezuzah. When he checks it again before seven years have passed, it has effectively been checked twice within seven years. Had the Gemara stated that a mezuzah must be checked once every seven years, we might have understood that the initial inspection before affixing it was sufficient, and that the next inspection could take place after seven years had passed. The Gemara therefore teaches that it must be checked twice within seven years, meaning that the second inspection must take place before the seven-year period ends. The same explanation applies to the requirement to check a public mezuzah twice every fifty years. The Aruch HaShulchan (se’if 1), based on Rashi’s explanation, writes that although a privately owned mezuzah ordinarily requires checking only twice every seven years, if it is located in an area with considerable moisture, it should be checked at least once a year. He adds that this was his own practice.

In Shaar HaTziyun (se’if katan 9), Rav Chaim Kanievsky zt”l writes that if a mezuzah was exposed to heavy rain, creating a concern that it became damaged, it must be checked immediately, just as tefillin that fall into water require inspection.

Must Hermetically Sealed Mezuzos Be Checked

Nowadays, this question requires further consideration, since many mezuzos are enclosed in cases that are almost completely airtight. Must they still be checked as required by the Shulchan Aruch?

Maran Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l ruled that a hermetically sealed mezuzah does not require checking at all.

However, Rav Chaim Kanievsky and Rav Nissim Karelitz zt”l, maintained that checking is still necessary. Their reasoning is that the poskim explain that changes in temperature, both heat and cold, can cause the letters to change or crack. Even when the mezuzah is hermetically sealed, the ink can still deteriorate, and it therefore requires checking twice every seven years. However, the Shulchan Gavoah (se’if katan 1) writes: Rashi explains that the reason for checking a mezuzah is the concern that it may have decayed or been stolen. This implies that checking is required specifically because of these concerns, and not because the letters may have become blurred. Accordingly, nowadays, when the custom is to place the mezuzah inside a glass tube, reed tube, or another protective case, as mentioned at the beginning of siman 289, to protect it from the moisture of the wall, as Tosafos explain in Bava Metzia (102a), there should be no need to check it. There is no concern that it has decayed, since the protective case preserves it. As for the concern that it was stolen, we can clearly see that it remains in its place. He concludes that this may explain why people have been lenient regarding checking mezuzos, to the extent that they do not check them even once every seven years.

We find several other poskim who rule similarly. Halichos Shlomo (Chapter 4, note 52) writes that regarding mezuzos placed inside the wall within a glass container, without touching the wall, people are not particular to check them twice every seven years. This was also the ruling of Maran Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv and Rav Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg zt”l, and I heard the same from my rebbi, Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl shlit”a. However, I saw an observation in the sefer Levushei Oz, which questions the words of the Shulchan Gavoah.

The practice of placing a mezuzah inside a protective tube is already mentioned in Maseches Mezuzah (2:10) and in the Gemara in Menachos (33b), which discuss placing a mezuzah inside a reed tube or another container. Nevertheless, the halachah still requires checking mezuzos. We therefore see that even when a mezuzah is placed inside a protective case, the aforementioned concerns remain. Furthermore, since Chazal instituted the requirement to check mezuzos, the enactment does not become nullified. There is also a concern that when the parchment is folded and inserted into the mezuzah case, portions of the letters may gradually become erased at the folds, making a letter appear split into two. The Mishkenos Yaakov (Yoreh Deah, siman 16) proves from this halachah that an obligation to check exists even when the concern involves only a miut hamatzui (a commonly occurring minority of cases). However, perhaps the requirement to check mezuzos applies even when the concern is less than a miut hamatzui, since living in a home without a kosher mezuzah involves danger, and chamira sakanta mei’issura — matters involving danger are treated more stringently than ordinary prohibitions. He therefore concludes that our mezuzos should indeed be checked.

Halachah Lemaaseh: Regarding a hermetically sealed mezuzah, one who does not check it has substantial halachic grounds upon which to rely. However, one who wishes to check it is deserving of a berachah.

If the mezuzah is exposed to sunlight or cold temperatures, it should preferably be checked twice every seven years.


Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabbanim of Beis Horaah KLY:

What Bracha Does One Make on a Wrap?

Q: Wraps have become a popular alternative to sandwiches. They are made from flour and are often eaten with meat, cheese, or vegetables, much like ordinary bread. However, since a wrap is extremely thin, does it retain the halachic status of bread, requiring Hamotzi and Birchas Hamazon, or is its bracha Mezonos?

A: The halacha distinguishes between different types of baked products made from flour. Not everything made from wheat flour is automatically considered bread, and the appearance and manner of preparation can affect its bracha. This distinction is discussed by the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 168:8).

The Mishnah Berurah (168:38) discusses a type of crepe known as valaplatkes, which was common in Prague. These were made from a belilah rakah (thin batter), which spread out during baking and produced an exceptionally thin and delicate product. Because of their extreme thinness, the Mishnah Berurah writes that they do not have the halachic status of bread at all. Consequently, their bracha is Mezonos, even if a person eats enough to constitute a full meal. This final point is significant. Ordinarily, there are baked products whose bracha is Mezonos when eaten as a snack, but changes to Hamotzi when one establishes a meal upon them. The crepes described by the Mishnah Berurah are different. Since they lack toras lechem, the status of bread altogether, eating a larger quantity cannot turn them into bread. Their bracha therefore remains Mezonos even when eaten as a meal. The question is whether modern wraps fall into this same category. After all, wraps are also unusually thin. Some contemporary poskim maintain that their thinness is sufficient to deprive them of tzuras hapas, the recognizable form and status of bread. According to this approach, a wrap is comparable to the crepes discussed by the Mishnah Berurah, and its bracha is Mezonos. Those who consider a wrap to lack the status of bread altogether maintain that even eating it as a full meal would not require Hamotzi. However, most poskim draw an important distinction between crepes and wraps. Crepes are prepared from a belilah rakah, a liquid batter that is poured onto the cooking surface. The result is extremely thin and delicate. Ordinary wheat wraps, by contrast, are made from a belilah avah, a thick dough of the kind used for bread. The dough is then rolled out until it becomes very thin, but its original consistency gives the finished wrap enough substance and firmness to retain tzuras hapas. In other words, the fact that something is thin does not, by itself, mean that it is no longer bread. The relevant question is whether the finished product still possesses the character of bread, and the consistency of the dough from which it was made is an important factor. As the Mishnah Berurah explains (168:36–37), even a relatively thin baked product may be considered ordinary bread when it retains the necessary qualities. Accordingly, under this approach, a wheat wrap is no different in principle from another thin form of bread. The fact that it is folded around a filling, rather than used for a sandwich in the usual way, does not remove its status as bread.

Summary: In practice, the accepted ruling for ordinary wraps made from wheat-flour dough is to wash and recite Hamotzi, followed by Birchas Hamazon. Nevertheless, one who recites Mezonos has poskim upon whom to rely. This discussion concerns wheat wraps; wraps made from corn or other flours are a different discussion


Does Mentioning Adonai Mitchell’s Name Present a Halachic Issue of Saying the Name of Hashem?

Q: There is a player on the New York Jets named “Adonai Mitchell.” Being that his first name is similar to the way we pronounce one of the names of Hashem, is there any halachic issue with mentioning him by name in ordinary conversation?

A: Before addressing the actual question, it is important to point out that this player’s name is pronounced slightly differently from the way we pronounce the name of Hashem. His name is pronounced “ADD-en-eye,” with the short “a” sound found in the word “add,” whereas the Shem Hashem is pronounced “ah-do-NAI,” beginning with the “ah” sound found in the word “father.” Accordingly, there is room to suggest that the question does not even begin, since the two pronunciations are not identical. Nevertheless, for the purpose of our discussion, we will assume that the similarity is sufficient to raise a genuine halachic question, although this is certainly not a foregone conclusion. Regarding someone whose name is “Shalom,” we find an interesting dispute among the poskim.

The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 84:1), rules that one may not greet another person with “Shalom” in the inner room of a beis hamerchatz (bathhouse), where people are undressed. The reason is that Shalom is one of the names of Hashem.

The Bach (Orach Chaim 84) and Magen Avraham (84:2) extend this prohibition to someone whose actual name is Shalom. According to them, one may not even call such a person by his name in the bathhouse, since Shalom is one of the names of Hashem.

The Taz (84:3), however, strongly disagrees. He argues that when someone calls his friend Shalom, he is not referring to Hashem or even wishing the person peace. He is merely using an individual’s name, and therefore sees no reason to prohibit it. Rav Moshe Feinstein zatzal is also reported to have permitted this, explaining that just as one may say “Elohim Acherim” when referring to false deities, despite “Elohim” also being a name of Hashem, so too one may call a person Shalom when clearly referring to that individual (Dibros Moshe Comment 58 on Perek “Yetzias Hashabbos page 301; also see Teshuvas Revevos Ephraim 1:7:2).

The Mishnah Berurah (84:6) writes that although the accepted practice follows the lenient opinion, a yerei Shamayim (G-d-fearing person) should be stringent, since many Acharonim prohibit it. At first glance, then, it would seem appropriate to be stringent in our case as well.

However, the Meir Oz (Siman 84 page 931) quotes Rav Chaim Kanievsky zatzal as ruling that me’ikar hadin (according to the basic halacha), one may pronounce “Elohim Acherim” when referring to avodah zarah, since in that context the word “Elohim” does not refer to Hashem at all. How can this be reconciled with the stringent position concerning someone named Shalom? It does not make sense that Rav Chaim would simply disregard the stringent opinions without even mentioning the dispute.

The Meir Oz suggests an interesting distinction. A person named Shalom is given a name associated with one of the middos (attributes) of Hashem, expressing the hope that he will reflect that attribute. Consequently, although one is referring to the individual, the name itself retains an association with Hashem, which explains why some poskim are stringent.

By contrast, “Elohim Acherim” is merely a way of identifying the avodah zarah being discussed, without invoking Hashem or His attributes. Based on this distinction, it would seem that in our case there is no substantial reason to be stringent. When someone refers to this football player by name, he is simply identifying that individual, without any intention of referring to Hashem or invoking one of His attributes. Accordingly, his name should be comparable to the expression “Elohim Acherim,” which is permissible me’ikar hadin. All the more so in our case, where it is not even clear that the pronunciation of his name presents a legitimate halachic issue in the first place, since it differs from the way the Shem Hashem is pronounced. Nevertheless, it is praiseworthy to alter the name slightly, such as saying “Donai,” or simply referring to him as “A.D.” This avoids becoming desensitized to pronouncing something resembling a Shem Hashem in ordinary conversation, and also prevents others from becoming desensitized to its kedushah.

Summary: There appears to be no halachic issue with referring to this player by name, since one is merely identifying an individual and has no intention whatsoever of mentioning the name of Hashem. This is especially true considering that his name is not even pronounced exactly like the Shem Hashem. Nevertheless, slightly altering the name is praiseworthy out of respect for its kedushah.